Which Mattress Topper is Best?

Anyone who wants to upgrade their double bed mattress topper without spending a fortune is likely to be a fan of a mattress topper. Look for one that has temperature-regulating features if you sleep hot or a wool model if you have allergies.

This hybrid topper blends memory foam and fiberfill to provide support and comfort. It has a hypoallergenic covering, and a comfortable top. Our tester found it be comfortable enough for back and stomach sleepers, and also provided plenty of pressure relief.

Tempur-Pedic Layla Memory Foam

The Tempur-Pedic Layla Memory Foam Topper is a great option for those looking to upgrade their mattress but don't want to invest in a new mattress. It provides a soft feeling, pressure relief and cooling technology. The topper has a 2" layer of soft memory foam, which is slow-responding and slow-reacting, which conforms to the body and alleviates pressure points. The breathable cover is designed to keep the topper cool through the night.

The top layer of the mattress is infused with copper-gel beads and Thermo-Gel technology to help it draw heat away from the sleeper's body, allowing for a more comfortable sleep. The mattress reduces motion transfer and is a great option for couples who sleep together. The topper is made from high-quality materials and has low environmental impact.

This mattress topper is available in two firmness levels medium and firm. The medium side is softer, and works best for back sleepers. The firm side provides more support and could be better for side sleepers or stomach sleepers.

Many customers who have purchased this padded mattress topper topper have reported a quick break-in period, with the mattress getting softer and more supportive as time passes. Some report a longer waiting time, however, and a slower response from the foam. Some have also complained that the mattress did not "off-gas" quickly enough, resulting in a noticeable chemical smell.

If you're a side or back sleeper suffering from pain in the hips, back or shoulders, this is an option worth considering. The softer side of this mattress cushions the hips and relieves pressure on the spine. However, if you're a heavy weight sleeper, this topper may not provide the level of support required to keep your spine in alignment.

This topper is ideal for back sleepers who weigh less. Its soft side cushions the hips and alleviates shoulders from pressure, helping to align the spine. However, heavyweight sleepers who opt for this type of mattress may not be comfortable due to the fact that it could sink too far and cause the hips to hurt.

Birch's Organic Mattress Topper

If you're looking for a mattress topper double bed made of organic wool, latex and cotton, look at the Plush Organic Topper from Birch. It's a two-inch thick topper that is made of the same natural materials as the Birch mattress and includes the company's signature organic cotton cover which promotes airflow between you and your mattress and prevents you from feeling stuck to it. The mattress is antimicrobial and hypoallergenic, so it is resistant to mold, mildew and bacterial infections.

The topper is also certified by OKEO-TEX and has a layer comprised of organic buckwheat the hulls. You can rest assured it's free of harmful chemicals and fertilizers. Buckwheat naturally breathes and allows for rapid heat dispersion. This can allow you stay cool throughout the night. The hulls are also great sources of protein, which can improve your sleep and boost energy levels.

It's also soft, similar to the Layla memory-foam topper. It is also made of natural fibers that regulate body temperature and help reduce friction between your sheets and the skin. The fibers are ineffective against common allergens like dust mites and pet dust. Additionally, the topper is a good option for those who have sensitive skin or back pain due to the fact that it's a natural insulator and can ward off heat buildup.

Another alternative is another option is the Avocado organic latex mattress protector, which is available in medium-firm and soft options that are good for a wide range of sleepers. It is two inches thicker and is made of Talalay latex organic cotton and New Zealand merino. The topper is priced a more than the Birch topper, however it is still a reasonable way to add luxury to your bed.

Both the Avocado Mattress Topper and the Birch Organic mattress Toppers cooling Topper have been designed to support your spine when you sleep. They are great for those suffering from pains and aches. Lower back pain is a typical complaint. Be aware that a mattress topper can't fix old mattresses that are creaking or sagging, nor will it stop you from developing a bad back or hip. If you are heavier than the average person, your hips may sink too deeply into the mattress, causing your back to arch and cause joint pain.

Sleep Innovations Memory Foam Topper

Memory foam toppers work great for those who like to sink deep into their mattress. The material is shaped to your body, evenly dispersing weight and keeping your spine, shoulders and hips in a straight line. They block motion which makes them a great choice for couples or co-sleepers. However, they can also hold heat, which is why it's crucial to choose a mattress topper made of memory foam that is infused with graphite, gel copper, or some other cooling material to avoid excessive heat and night sweats.

The Sleep Innovations mattress topper is an affordable mid-priced option that's infused with cooling gel to help to prevent overheating. It also has a unique honeycomb design that helps keep the cover cool and airy. The cover can be machine washed, which is an excellent feature given the price of this mattress topper. Another feature that is appealing is the elastic band on each corner that anchor the topper in place so that it doesn't slide across the sofa bed mattress topper during sleep.

This memory foam topper is classified as medium, meaning it's not as firm as some of the other choices on our list, but it still provides ample support for most sleepers. The topper's bottom layer is made up of two inches of memory foam that molds well, relieving pressure points and softerening the mattress. It's topped by an additional layer of plush fiber filling that feels similar to a soft pillow and adds additional cushioning.

Like many memory foam toppers, this one can be a bit warm for those who sleep hot, but the cooling gel can aid in preventing overheating. It's also more expensive than other options however you can find it on sale at online retailers or look out for an Casper deal.

Think about a topper made of latex for a more traditional mattress. It is known for its durability and longevity, and it's naturally antimicrobial, hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites. It's also comfortable than memory foam, so it could be ideal for hot sleepers. It is also more responsive than memory foam and can offer adequate support for back and stomach sleepers.

Nolah Beds Memory Foam Topper

The Nolah Beds memory foam topper is a more substantial layer that produces a more noticeable change in the firmness of a mattress. It is available in six standard mattress sizes and can be placed directly on top of the existing mattress. It's not as waterproof as a mattress cover, so it doesn't protect the mattress from liquid spills or other contaminants. It's also more expensive than a mattress pad with the average queen-sized topper priced between $150 and $400.

This topper is perfect for those who feel their mattress is too soft. It features a 3.5-inch layer of memory foam gel which helps to cradle and relieve pressure points, while the Nolah AirFoam core is durable and elasticity. This combination of materials is ideal for all types of sleepers.

Similar to the Nolah Original 10, this mattress is designed for side sleepers and features a soft feel that is designed to cradle and support pressure points. The Nolah Limited Edition 10 has more durable covers constructed of breathable Tencel-lyocell.

Nolah mattresses are made in the United States. The company claims that they are cooler than other memory-foam mattresses due to their unique foam mattress topper that doesn't trap heat. The Nolah Original 10 has two inches of Nolah airfoam on the top of a layer of high-resilience memory foam. This layer is specifically designed to allow the mattress to last longer and reduce the effects of movement.

Who Tested It: Strategist senior editor Maxine Builder

Though the Nolah mattress is an innerspring model, it's made to be much cooler than a typical spring-coil mattress. The mattress is made up of a natural cotton pillow top that is surrounded by a layer of eco-friendly memory foam. This layer is set on recycled steel coils and a poly foam bottom. The coils are individually wrapped, a characteristic usually reserved for high-end luxurious models. This makes it more robust and flexible than the traditional mattress made by Saatva that Strategist writer Kelsey Darragh tested in 2020. The only downside is that the Nolah mattress can be a bit warm because of its all-foam construction.